However, Dianne notes a troubling trend: many schools claim to be "student-centered" (Developmental) or "real-world" (Apprenticeship) while actually running Transmission behind the scenes. The result is a kind of that frustrates everyone.
Dianne’s thesis is provocative: You cannot fix a school by adding programs. You must identify its root model and decide whether to switch frameworks entirely. school models dianne
Develops voice, civic courage, ethical reasoning, and adaptability. Highly engaging for students who reject traditional authority. Pathologies: Can feel chaotic to outsiders; relies heavily on skilled, reflective teachers. May struggle to cover standardized content. Not easily assessed with traditional metrics. Example: Sudbury Valley School (democratic free school), some critical pedagogy classrooms, social-justice-focused academies. Dianne’s challenge: "The transformative model asks not ‘What will you become?’ but ‘What kind of world do you want to help build?’" Dianne’s Core Insight: Models Can’t Be Mixed Without Dominance One of Dianne’s most important contributions is the Principle of Model Dominance : While schools may borrow elements from multiple models, one model will inevitably dominate the hidden curriculum—the implicit messages about what school is for . However, Dianne notes a troubling trend: many schools
High engagement, deep procedural knowledge, clear relevance. Builds craft and persistence. Pathologies: Can neglect abstract or theoretical knowledge not immediately useful. Requires low student-teacher ratios and expert practitioners as teachers—expensive. Example: Internship-heavy high schools (e.g., Big Picture Learning), trade schools, project-based learning (PBL) when done with fidelity. Dianne’s insight: "The apprenticeship model answers the student question, ‘When will I ever use this?’ before it is asked." Model 4: The Transformative Model (The "Polis School") Core Metaphor: The school as a democratic community or social movement. Primary Goal: Liberation and agency—changing the self and society. Teacher Role: Co-learner and critical guide. Student Role: Co-creator of curriculum and community norms. You must identify its root model and decide
Scalable, measurable, predictable. Produces shared cultural literacy. Pathologies: Student disengagement, "schooling as compliance," anxiety around high-stakes testing. Example: Lecture-based high schools, many test-prep academies. Dianne’s warning: "When a school’s only metric is recall, it produces students who cannot ask a good question." Model 2: The Developmental Model (The "Garden School") Core Metaphor: The school as a greenhouse or garden. Primary Goal: Nurturing the whole child—cognitive, emotional, social, physical. Teacher Role: Facilitator and observer of natural growth. Student Role: Active constructor of meaning.
The Transmission Model is what most people picture when they hear "traditional school." Originating from the Industrial Revolution, it treats curriculum as a fixed body of facts to be deposited into students before they are tested for cracks. Dianne notes that this model excels at sorting—identifying who can memorize quickly and follow instructions—but fails at deep inquiry.
The Transformative Model is the rarest and most radical. Inspired by Paulo Freire, bell hooks, and democratic free schools, it sees education as inherently political. The purpose is not just to learn facts or skills but to question systems of power, develop critical consciousness, and practice collective decision-making. Students help design rules, resolve conflicts democratically, and pursue inquiries that matter to their lived experience.