((full)) - Allison Carr Mutha Magazine

That smudge, though? It’s not a flaw. It’s the proof of life. It’s the thumbprint of presence. It’s the mark that says you were there, in the trenches, reaching in to wipe the face of someone who needed you.

My daughter eventually handed me back the phone. She had moved on to the next photo: a crisp, perfect shot of our dog sleeping. She smiled, said “Puppy,” and ran off to destroy the living room.

She pointed to it. “Mama. Sad.”

By Allison Carr

This is what I want to tell the woman who is reading this in the bathtub while her partner wrangles the toddler, or the one hiding in the Target parking lot for ten extra minutes just to hear herself think. You are not failing because your kitchen is a disaster zone. You are not a bad mother because you did not make the sensory bin from Pinterest. You are not broken because you sometimes miss the silence. allison carr mutha magazine

I think about that photo my daughter found. The “sad” one. In it, I am not performing. I am not trying to be a “good mom” for the ‘gram. I am just being a mom. My hand is dirty. The light is fluorescent. The moment is ugly. And yet, that is the photo she was drawn to. Not the Easter portrait. Not the beach sunset. The Tuesday morning apocalypse.

I watched her over the rim of my coffee mug. She swiped past the curated shots—the ones where the light is golden, her hair is brushed, and she is smiling not because she is happy, but because I was making barnyard animal sounds behind the lens. She paused on a blurry one. I had taken it at 6:00 AM on a Tuesday. She is in her diaper, yogurt in her hair, screaming because the blue cup was, tragically, the wrong blue cup. In the frame, my own hand is visible, reaching in to wipe her face, a smudge of my thumbprint on the lens. That smudge, though

There is a specific grief in that realization. Not a tragedy, but a low-grade mourning for the woman you used to be—the one who could read a novel for three hours on a Sunday, the one whose body belonged only to her, the one who didn’t know the precise texture of vomit at 2:00 AM versus 4:00 AM. We don’t talk about that grief enough. We talk about postpartum depression and anxiety (thank god, finally), but we don’t talk about the mundane melancholy of missing your old self while simultaneously holding the new self you would die for.